Saying that NGOs are not sustainable because they depend on donations is like saying that companies are not sustainable because they depend on sales.
By Leonardo Letelier and Beatriz Cardoso
If in Brazil 241% of companies close before two years of operation (according to the 2013 Sebrae Census) and in the US half do not survive more than four years (according to the average of several studies), why do we insist on saying that NGOs are not sustainable, even knowing that there are some that have been in existence for over a hundred years?
The definition of financial sustainability is not that complicated: a company, a social organization or even a government is sustainable if it receives more than it spends. When this does not happen, the consequences are clear: companies go bankrupt and social organizations close.
An NGO’s income comes from donations; a company’s income comes from the sale of a product or service. Both are “valid” sources of income — the only difference is that donations are made to benefit third parties, while purchases are made to benefit the buyer. Saying that NGOs are not sustainable because they depend on donations is like saying that companies are not sustainable because they depend on sales.
The challenge of sustainability is not due to the choice of NGO model. Most of them are or should be sustainable, considering that donations are a “legitimate” source of income. Instead of insisting on the logic of commercial revenue and proposing inadequate solutions to the challenges of the third sector, we should invest in the growth of a culture of philanthropy and donation. Each of us can get involved by allocating a small portion of our income or assets to social challenges.
It is important to emphasize that the point here is not to argue that all social organizations are financially sustainable — nor are companies. But rather to challenge the idea that NGOs have to be sustainable only through generating commercial revenue.
The real challenge for any organization is to have a source of income that is predictable, diversified and greater than its costs. For an NGO, having a single donor is as bad as for a company having a single buyer. Following the same logic, having a base of small, medium and large donors, national and international, individuals and legal entities, is as good as a company having a diversified buyer base.
There are still two other factors that unbalance the field of comparisons between these two forms of organization.
The first is that there is much more money to invest in the “commercial” world than in the “social” world. The difference in order of magnitude becomes clear when comparing the figures quoted in the stock and credit markets (trillions of reais) to any estimate from the social sector (at Sitawi we use R$30 billion).
The second, which we have influence over, is that society — that is, you and me — is willing to pay more than the “cost” for a can of carbonated water with sugar and carcinogenic chemicals or any other product. It is with this difference between revenue and cost that companies attract good professionals with adequate salaries, invest in marketing and innovation and serve more consumers, which generates more resources to keep the wheel turning, in addition to creating conditions for innovation and knowledge production, necessary for any sector to advance.
However, generally speaking, when we finance a social intervention, we do not accept paying more than its direct cost, such as soup or shelter for a homeless person. The obvious consequence of this is that social organizations have less qualified professionals than ideal, invest little, have difficulty innovating and do not scale.
If we believe that neither the market nor the government will solve all problems, we need an engaged civil society with strong organizations and creative solutions.
If you want to help create a stronger culture of giving and make social change possible, do your part: when you give your child an allowance, divide it into three envelopes: one for him/her to save, one for him/her to spend, and a third for him/her to donate. If you want to do something yourself, donate, donate more, and donate better. We sincerely hope you do both.
Leonardo Letelier is the executive director of Sitawi Finanças do Bem (a social finance institution) and Beatriz Cardoso is the executive director of the Education Laboratory
Source: http://oglobo.globo.com/opiniao/pais-precisa-de-mais-investidores-sociais-15593906